Learn more about our policy experts.

Media Contacts

Angela Bradbery, Director of Communications
w. (202) 588-7741
c. (202) 503-6768
abradbery@citizen.org, Twitter

Barbara Holzer, Broadcast Manager
w. (202) 588-7716
bholzer@citizen.org

Karilyn Gower, Press Officer
w. (202) 588-7779
kgower@citizen.org

Other Important Links

Press Release Database
Citizen Vox blog
Texas Vox blog
Consumer Law and Policy blog
Energy Vox blog
Eyes on Trade blog
Facebook/publiccitizen

Follow us on Twitter

 

March 17, 2003

Public Citizen Urges Texas Supreme Court to Overturn Ruling That Would Strand Victims of Financial Fraud, Insulate Companies

Dean Witter Brokerage Firm Should Be Liable for Employee’s Fraud

AUSTIN, Texas – Public Citizen today urged the Texas Supreme Court to review a ruling that, if allowed to stand, would insulate brokerage firms and other financial institutions from most, if not all, intentional fraud perpetrated by their employees.

The ruling makes it far less likely that victims of fraud will be compensated for their losses. It also would send a message to firms that they won’t have to monitor their employees as closely as they do now, Public Citizen said in an amicus brief.

Courts throughout the country have ruled that employers are liable for their workers’ misdeeds when the workers commit those acts as part of their general scope of authority – that is, when the employer has the right and power to direct and control the worker in the performance of the act that caused the harm.

In the case, Millan v. Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. , 90 S.W.3d 760, the Fourth District Court of Appeals in San Antonio acknowledged that the Dean Witter employee in question, Miguel Millan, stole about $287,000 over a three-year period from his mother’s Dean Witter account that he had established in his role as a Dean Witter broker. Millan engaged in a series of deceitful acts, such as forging his mother’s name on checks and creating false account statements. Dean Witter was hardly blameless, as it failed, for instance, to follow special rules for oversight of familial accounts.

The Court of Appeals ruled last year that, because Dean Witter had not specifically authorized Millan to engage in fraud, the brokerage firm was not liable for Millan’s wrongdoing.

But the appellate court was confusing specific authority with the general authority that Dean Witter had given Millan, Public Citizen said in the brief. If employers could be held liable only for acts they specifically authorized, employers would usually escape liability for fraud, because they would never authorize an employee to steal, the brief said.

"The Court of Appeals should have focused on Miguel’s general acts – the opening of the Dean Witter account, the receipt of money for investment, and the like," the brief says. "That conduct was in furtherance of the employer’s business, and [these] were exactly the kinds of acts that Miguel was hired to do."

Recent corporate scandals have shown that there is increased need to protect consumers from abuse whether it be at the hands of brokers, accounting firms, or other corporate actors, and yet the Court of Appeals decision moves in the other direction. The brief notes that, unless the Texas Supreme Court steps in, defrauded Texans will have little recourse, because the industry will hide behind its employees, who don’t have the resources to fully compensate their victims, said Brian Wolfman, an attorney with the Public Citizen Litigation Group, who filed the brief.

"The appellate court ruling is very disturbing because it flies in the face of settled law," Wolfman said. "If the Texas Supreme Court doesn’t overturn this decision, financial institutions will have far less incentive to oversee their employees’ conduct. Fraud victims could be left out in the cold."

Said Tom "Smitty" Smith, director of Public Citizen’s Texas office, "If the appellate court ruling stands, big corporations would be shielded, while consumers will be stripped of their assets and left without many options to recoup their losses."

To read Public Citizen’s brief, click here.

###

Copyright © 2014 Public Citizen. Some rights reserved. Non-commercial use of text and images in which Public Citizen holds the copyright is permitted, with attribution, under the terms and conditions of a Creative Commons License. This Web site is shared by Public Citizen Inc. and Public Citizen Foundation. Learn More about the distinction between these two components of Public Citizen.


Public Citizen, Inc. and Public Citizen Foundation

 

Together, two separate corporate entities called Public Citizen, Inc. and Public Citizen Foundation, Inc., form Public Citizen. Both entities are part of the same overall organization, and this Web site refers to the two organizations collectively as Public Citizen.

Although the work of the two components overlaps, some activities are done by one component and not the other. The primary distinction is with respect to lobbying activity. Public Citizen, Inc., an IRS § 501(c)(4) entity, lobbies Congress to advance Public Citizen’s mission of protecting public health and safety, advancing government transparency, and urging corporate accountability. Public Citizen Foundation, however, is an IRS § 501(c)(3) organization. Accordingly, its ability to engage in lobbying is limited by federal law, but it may receive donations that are tax-deductible by the contributor. Public Citizen Inc. does most of the lobbying activity discussed on the Public Citizen Web site. Public Citizen Foundation performs most of the litigation and education activities discussed on the Web site.

You may make a contribution to Public Citizen, Inc., Public Citizen Foundation, or both. Contributions to both organizations are used to support our public interest work. However, each Public Citizen component will use only the funds contributed directly to it to carry out the activities it conducts as part of Public Citizen’s mission. Only gifts to the Foundation are tax-deductible. Individuals who want to join Public Citizen should make a contribution to Public Citizen, Inc., which will not be tax deductible.

 

To become a member of Public Citizen, click here.
To become a member and make an additional tax-deductible donation to Public Citizen Foundation, click here.