Large Businesses Are Now “Small” under Trump’s Latest Big Business Handout
By Katie Tracy
President Trump’s Small Business Administration (SBA) is proposing a massive expansion of the definition of “small business” to add roughly 114,000 U.S. firms, many previously deemed too big to qualify. Real small businesses have voiced considerable opposition because it would make those larger firms eligible for benefits designed to help smaller firms compete on a level playing field.
One benefit intended only for small businesses is dedicated support from the SBA Office of Advocacy, an office charged with lifting up small business voices in government decisionmaking. If the SBA size standards proposal becomes final, small business interests would be diluted with medium and large businesses’ disparate interests.
Public Citizen and our allies have often called out the SBA Office of Advocacy for parroting Big Business talking points in favor of repealing and weakening public safeguards, frequently to the disadvantage of the small businesses it is legally required to represent. If finalized, this new SBA rule would help legitimize Advocacy’s lawlessness in pushing an anti-regulatory corporate agenda and further drowning out the voice of small businesses.
The Office of Advocacy is, unsurprisingly, supporting the SBA proposal and the large businesses that benefit from it despite vehement small business pushback. In its supporting statement, the office downplayed the impact, reframing a substantial 10% growth in federal contractors considered “small” as a “narrow, targeted adjustment to eligibility.” Meanwhile, numerous outlets have called the proposal a sweeping overhaul, the largest in decades, if not ever.
The SBA rulemaking docket is replete with thousands of comments opposing the change. One comment states, “There is no logical explanation for how changing the definition of ‘small business’ to include companies that are larger helps ‘small businesses.’” Another commenter writes, “The absolute attack on small business with this change is incredible and very much a complete acknowledgment of our federal government’s complete lack of understanding of what it is to be a small business.”
Expanding the size standards could also trigger additional analysis and paperwork requirements under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA) and further expand the Office of Advocacy’s power. The office is tasked with ensuring agency compliance with the RFA. The law requires agencies to assess whether proposed regulations would have a “significant effect on a substantial number of small entities,” and seek to minimize such effects. Adding more businesses to the definition means RFA analyses could be required more often, which would delay agencies from finalizing new safeguards and strengthening existing ones.
The RFA tasks the Office of Advocacy with submitting an annual compliance report to Congress, which is often ideologically bent and one-sided. The law also permits the Chief Counsel of Advocacy to submit “friend of the court” briefs to courts reviewing regulations. Expanding the SBA size standards could expand the RFA’s applicability and give the office another opportunity to push its big business agenda before Congress and the courts.
Given Advocacy’s history of opposing federal safeguards, the expanded role and influence the office would gain from SBA’s proposal would harm small businesses that depend on strong rules. Due to the procedural delays and extra opportunity for big business voices to influence the process, it would also hinder federal agencies from preventing large corporations from passing their harm onto American families and communities.
SBA’s proposal and Office of Advocacy’s support for it exemplifies the depths large corporations have gone to capture the regulatory process. The Office of Advocacy has been known in Washington, DC, as a big business mouthpiece for years, and this rulemaking shows that major corporations have now fully captured it. Congress should move swiftly to abolish this lawless office and should conduct immediate oversight over corporate influence at the SBA.
For small businesses and the public broadly, SBA is accepting comments on its revised size standards and its methodology until November 20th. Make sure your voice is heard by submitting comments ahead of the deadline and calling your members of Congress.