May 31, 2011
CIA Should Respond to Request for Decades-Old Records on Opus Dei, Public Citizen Tells Court
Acknowledging Existence of Records Would Not Reveal Intelligence Sources or Undermine National Security, Group Argues
WASHINGTON, D.C. – The CIA should fully respond to a historian’s request for decades-old CIA records about the Catholic group Opus Dei, Public Citizen said in a motion filed late Monday in the Southern District of New York on behalf of a historian.
Simply acknowledging whether the CIA possesses these records, which are between 31 and 64 years old, would neither reveal intelligence sources and methods nor undermine national security, Public Citizen contends in the motion for partial summary judgment.
The case began in June 2009 when Harry Cason, who is working toward his Ph.D. at the City University of New York, submitted a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to the CIA. Cason is working on a dissertation about U.S. involvement in Spain’s transformation during Francisco Franco’s regime. He asked for any records or information about Opus Dei generated before 1980. He cited two reports he knew of, one completed in 1952 and another in 1964 that was referenced in a letter from an official at the American Embassy in Madrid to a Department of State official.
The CIA refused to fully respond to Cason’s request. Although it released 207 pages of records, it also said that it couldn’t confirm or deny the existence of other records responsive to the request. It said that acknowledging the existence or nonexistence of responsive records would itself reveal information that is exempt under FOIA – i.e., by revealing whether the agency has records about a covert operation or a confidential source.
Seeking a more substantive response, Cason sued the CIA on Jan. 3.
Representing Cason, Public Citizen argued in the motion that revealing the mere existence of decades-old records on Opus Dei would not harm national security or reveal CIA sources or methods.
“The CIA should not be able to avoid the disclosure requirements of FOIA by making vague appeals to national security, completely divorced from the records requested in this case,” said Michael Page, the Public Citizen attorney handling the case. “Not only are the records subject to automatic declassification because of their age, but it is implausible that the existence of a half-century-old interest in Opus Dei would undermine national security.”
In addition, he said, it defies logic that acknowledging the existence or nonexistence of Opus Dei records would reveal an intelligence source or method.
“Acknowledging whether these records exist would say nothing about the CIA’s surveillance capabilities,” Page said. “Whether the CIA had the ability to monitor Opus Dei before the Internet, cell phones and other modern technologies existed says nothing about the agency’s capabilities today.”
What’s more, because the CIA released some records about Opus Dei, acknowledging the existence of additional records would not compromise intelligence gathering, Page said.
Public Citizen is a national, nonprofit consumer advocacy organization based in Washington, D.C.