AA v. Department of State
In 2025, President Trump issued proclamations banning entry of nationals from certain countries into the United States, but exempted asylees and individuals seeking asylum. In implemented these proclamations, the Department of State adopted a policy that separates U.S.-based asylum holders from their spouses and children, although by statute those family members may seek and be granted the same asylum status. In this case, seven asylees challenged that policy, alleging three claims under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). The district court ruled in their favor and vacated the policy.
The government appealed to the Fourth Circuit. Among other arguments, the government asserts that the APA does not authorize courts to vacate unlawful agency actions or, if it does, authorizes them to do so only as to the specific plaintiffs in a case. Public Citizen filed an amicus brief explaining why the government’s view is contrary to the APA’s text and history, runs counter to the long-held view of the courts, and poses intractable practical problems.